Commentary: OSAA’s proposed move to split Class 6A football playoffs misses mark, but there’s a better solution


The Oregon College Routines Association is seriously looking at a proposal that would split its 6A soccer classification for the duration of the playoffs.

In just one division, the major 16 teams in the remaining OSAA rankings, with some adjustments for league champions. In the other division, absolutely everyone else.

What do we contact this second division? The Have Nots Championship? Course 5½A? The Not Rather Fantastic Plenty of playoffs? Yay We’re No. 17 Championship?

It’s a move teed up to mock, and that’s particularly what some are carrying out on social media. Give everybody a trophy, they say.

Which is missing the place.

The OSAA acknowledges there is a competitive problem. This isn’t about handing out extra trophies, but leveling the enjoying subject. As it now stands, most educational facilities in Class 6A have no likelihood to acquire a championship in soccer.

Contemplate the earlier 10 many years of state championships. Out of a achievable 20 teams to play in the championship online games, only 9 faculties produced the quality. For the semifinals, with 40 berths at stake, just 13 universities. For the quarterfinals, 26 faculties filled the 80 berths on the line.

It is a large amount of sameness. Of the 10 playoff quarterfinals, Jesuit certified for all, Central Catholic for 9. Tigard, Sheldon and West Linn have created the quarterfinals in 7 of 10, Lake Oswego in six.

In the meantime, the state’s a few major educational institutions by enrollment — David Douglas, Reynolds, Westview— haven’t attained the quarterfinals after in the earlier 10 many years. David Douglas hasn’t gained a playoff activity given that 2011. Reynolds gained a initial-round recreation in 2018, its initially because 1997.

For some educational institutions, it’s an economics issue. Most of the state’s most successful football programs have plentiful sources, ranging from good amenities to people that can manage to spend for private teaching. Numerous of the faculties continuously squeezed from playoff operates have learners who can scarcely pay for the cleats, let by itself spend for a private trainer or a quarterback mentor.

Evidently, there’s a problem.

But basically splitting 6A every single postseason into two divisions, providing groups ranked beneath No. 16 a shot at a consolation prize, is a horrible strategy.

Outside of mom and dad and good friends, couple of will shell out awareness to these playoffs. Have you attended the consolation rounds at a point out basketball event? Everybody has a segment of the gymnasium to by themselves.

A person distinguished 6A football mentor I spoke to stated he’s not listened to from a single mentor who thinks the OSAA’s secondary 6A playoff is a superior thought. But his ears perked up when I laid out an alternative system.

In a nutshell, split 6A throughout the regular period and playoffs into two divisions for football: an Open up division and a 6A division. This recognizes there obviously are faculties with financial and other benefits, ranges the competitive playing subject, nonetheless preserves the credibility of the 6A division.

The Open division is composed of 16 teams, split into two 8-workforce regular time leagues. The remaining faculties perform in the 6A division. At this time, which is 31. Shut enough to divide into four leagues.

Which groups play in the Open division? For starters, Jesuit and Central Catholic are in. As non-public faculties with enrollment prerequisites that have no boundaries, they must participate in in the Open up division.

From there, use no matter what standards you’d like to make a decision which plans generally dominate the state, but here are a number of: an average of the OSAA rankings from the previous five many years, and latest playoff resumes. The leading 14 be part of Central Catholic and Jesuit.

In Open, teams engage in 7 frequent-season game titles versus teams in their league, and two non-leaguers versus schools of their deciding on. The playoffs consist of 12 groups. The leading six in just about every league qualify for postseason, the best two in each individual league obtaining a 1st-spherical bye.

In Class 6A, it’s a 16-staff playoff. The leading four from each league progress.

Straightforward peasy.

Now for the twist. There is a two-calendar year cycle for Open. Just after two a long time, the worst four performing Open up groups – utilizing established requirements – fall down to 6A for the forthcoming two years. The major 4 teams from 6A are promoted to Open up.


Oregon’s 6A soccer playoffs need to have reinvention. As it at this time stands, there is an unfair equilibrium. But transforming the playoffs shouldn’t involve a shortcut, as the OSAA proposes. Confess there is a problem, and generate a authentic solution.

— Nick Daschel | [email protected] | @nickdaschel


Supply hyperlink